For the dedicated home barista, few topics generate more discussion than the choice of brew group. Among the most hotly contested debates in the prosumer espresso community is the comparison between ring group machines and e-61 cartridge heater groups.
Both offer excellent performance, but their internal mechanics, heat-up times, temperature stability and user experience differ in ways that directly impact your daily workflow and espresso quality.
This review will explore how each system works, what kind of user each is best suited for, and how they compare in real-world prosumer use—where precision, control, and routine usability all matter.
⸻
Understanding the Brew Group Technologies
- Ring Group Machines
Ring group designs are typically found on machines like the Profitec Go, Move and Pro 300 as well as some other brands. These groups are compact, often thermally integrated with the boiler or a dedicated thermoblock, and are electrically heated or thermosyphon-fed. They’re engineered for quick heat-up and excellent temperature consistency at the point of extraction.
A ring group is characterised by:
• A flat “ring” that surrounds the group, often heated via a PID-controlled circuit. Whilst some vendors market these
groups as “saturated”, that definition is not really correct.
• More direct control over temperature, allowing it to change rapidly and stabilise quickly.
• Smaller thermal mass than an e-61, contributing to fast startup times and responsiveness.
- e-61 Cartridge Heater Group Machines
The traditional e-61 group, invented in 1961, is known for its durability, mechanical pre-infusion, and thermosyphon heat exchange design. Modern adaptations often add cartridge heaters and PID control, aiming to reduce sluggish thermal response while preserving its legendary temperature stability.
Key features of e-61 cartridge heater groups include:
• A large brass group with integrated thermosiphon and added electric heating for faster warm-up.
• Mechanical pre-infusion via a spring-loaded cam system.
• High thermal inertia, resulting in stable brew temps during long sessions.
⸻
Warm-Up Time and Workflow Efficiency
A major pain point for prosumers is warm-up time, especially in the age of quick-start appliances. Here’s how the two compare:
• Ring Group Machines (e.g: Profitec Pro 300, Profitec Go, Profitec Move) can be ready to brew in as little as 5–10 minutes, particularly when paired with fast-heating boilers or thermoblocks. This makes them ideal for weekday users who want high-quality espresso without the long wait.
• e-61 Cartridge-Heated Groups (e.g: ECM Synchronika II) still require more time than ring group machines to fully stabilise both group and boiler. Even with cartridge heating, the large mass of brass takes time to come to equilibrium. While some users use smart plugs or timers to pre-heat machines, these can add a layer of complexity.
Winner: Ring group for speed and weekday usability.
⸻
Temperature Control and PID Performance
Temperature management is one of the key advantages of modern espresso machines. PID controllers have elevated both ring group and e-61 systems, but implementation differs:
• Ring Groups are often more responsive to PID adjustments. Because the brew path is shorter and the group has lower thermal mass, temperature changes are reflected faster.
• e-61 Groups tend to have slower thermal response, even with cartridge heaters. Temperature changes made through the PID controller may take 15–20 minutes to be fully reflected at the group. However, once stabilised, they maintain temperature exceptionally well over multiple shots. That said, fantastic espresso can be produced in under 10 minutes with some cartridge heater machines.
Winner: Ring group for agility; e-61 for stability in back-to-back scenarios- dependent on how the PID allows the cartridge heaters to operate. We note here that whilst an e-61 group may be cartridge heated, some e-61 machines only deploy cartridges in initial heating, rather than for temperature management. Other e-61 machines (e.g: Profitec Pro 700) will simply overheat the brew boiler as a means of gaining earlier stability and then request a flush of the group to allow it to revert to brew temperature.
⸻
Preinfusion and Shot Quality
Preinfusion can make or break a shot, particularly with lighter roasts. Here’s how each group handles it:
• e-61 Groups offer true mechanical pre-infusion. When the lever is lifted halfway, water saturates the puck under low pressure before the pump kicks in. This natural, unpressurised bloom softens extraction and can improve shot consistency with challenging coffees. Many contemporary e-61 machines now allow fine control of both active and passive preinfusion.
• Ring Groups typically rely on programmable pump-based pre-infusion or simple ramp-up via rotary/vibration pumps. It’s also effective, but may not feel as tactile or nuanced as a mechanical system.
Shot quality on both platforms can be exceptional.
Winner: too close to call.
⸻
Maintenance and Longevity
• e-61 Groups are mechanical, rebuildable, and nearly eternal. Parts are widely available and many prosumers enjoy the ritual of cam service and lever tuning. However, descaling and maintaining the thermosiphon system can be more involved.
• Ring Groups, especially those in compact machines, are often easier to descale and service. However, some contain more proprietary parts or integrated components that are less user-serviceable.
Winner: e-61 for tinkerers and long-term parts availability; Ring group for simplicity.
⸻
Aesthetic and Ergonomic Differences
The e-61 group has iconic appeal—sleek levers, polished chrome, and a tactile ritual that many associate with “real espresso.” Its design is vintage but functional. The ring group, by contrast, often appears minimalist or clinical, and lacks that same mechanical drama.
However, some prosumers prefer the cleaner aesthetic and compact footprint of ring group machines, especially in modern kitchens where space is limited.
Winner: Tie, depending on taste: vintage ritual vs. modern minimalism.
⸻
Ideal Users and Machine Examples
e-61 Cartridge Heater Group – Ideal For:
• Prosumer users who brew multiple drinks in a row.
• Espresso purists who want inbuilt mechanical pre-infusion.
• Tinkerers and those who value long-term repairability.
• Examples: ECM Synchronika II.
Ring Group – Ideal For:
• Users seeking speed and daily convenience.
• Modern espresso enthusiasts who dial in different beans frequently.
• Those with space or power constraints.
• Examples: Profitec Pro 300, Profitec Move.
⸻
Conclusion: Which Is Right for You?
If you’re a weekday warrior who wants fast startup, modern design, and tight control over temperature, a ring group espresso machine is likely your ideal match. The quicker heat-up time and responsive PID control make them incredibly user-friendly and adaptable to diverse coffee styles.
If you value tradition, enjoy tinkering, or routinely serve multiple drinks in a row, the e-61 cartridge heater group remains a top-tier choice. The tactile engagement and consistent thermal performance can elevate the espresso ritual into an art form.
Ultimately, the right machine is the one that fits your daily lifestyle, not just your taste in espresso.
⸻
Final Verdict Summary
Ring Group
Warm-Up Time ✅ Fast (5–10 min)
Temperature Control ✅ Agile PID
Pre-Infusion ⚠️ Basic (pump-based)
Maintenance ✅ Easy
Shot Quality ✅ High (with tuning)
Aesthetic ⚖️ Modern
e-61 Cartridge Heater Group
Warm-Up Time ❌ Slow(er) although you will probably have espresso stability in <10 minutes. You will have to wait longer for steam though.
Temperature Control ⚖️ Stable but slow to change
Pre-Infusion ✅ Mechanical and tactile
Maintenance ⚠️ Involved but rebuildable
Shot Quality ✅ High and forgiving
Aesthetic ⚖️ Classic